Filmmakers seem to struggle with making a Judge Dredd film that will work for mainstream audiences. Danny Cannon's 1995 attempt, Judge Dredd, starring Sylvester Stallone, has garnered a bad reputation and although this 2012 film was better received, it didn't do well enough to warrant a sequel. It's a bit of a shame as there's a lot to like about this film, and it's one of my personal favourite films to adapt a comic book character.
The Stallone film tried to introduce Judge Dredd by cramming in a lot of different elements of 2000AD lore, including Rico, the Angel Gang and the ABC Warriors. By contrast, this film goes small scale and most of the action taking place within the Peachtrees tower building. Dredd and new trainee Anderson are investigating a triple homicide. They locate the killer, Kay, inside the tower block, but the Preachtrees gang leader, known as Ma-Ma, reacts by initiating war protocols and locking down the building. Dredd and Anderson must try to survive as they are hunted by gang members while using bullets and Anderson's psychic ability. All the while they drag along their suspect, Kay with them. Eventually they uncover Ma-Ma's secret creation of the drug-slo-mo. It's not clear whether the the decision to make the film small was for budgetary reasons but it was still a good one. The small scale nature of the threat gives us a day in the life of Dredd, and a decent idea of what Mega City One is like that could have been explored in future sequels.
The casting in this film is pretty good. Karl Urban is a decent enough Judge Dredd and it was pretty bold of the filmmakers to keep Dredd under his helmet and not showcase their star, but it was ultimately the right decision. Olivia Thirby gets to be the heart of film as Cassandra Anderson. Lena Hedy is also pretty good as the villainous Ma-Ma, choosing to play the character with cool energy rather than for loud and over the top. I'm not quite sure the role was written for such a young actor, given that her backstory is described as 'block legend' and there is little evidence of her past. Nevertheless, this works well.
The rest of the cast are decent. Wood Harris sticks in the mind as Kay, the clansmen and suspected murderer that Dredd and Anderson are forced to drag around for a large part of the film. . It's also fun seeing Domhnall Gleeson playing a victimised security controller, a nice contrast to his more powerful role as General Hux in Star Wars.
The film has quite striking visuals. Peachtrees is a wonderful graffiti filled environment. The effects work is pretty nice with slomo, making glass shards and flecks of blood look beautiful. Paul Leonard-Morgan's industrial score also helps create a decent atmosphere.
Ultimately this is not a groundbreaking piece of cinema, but a pretty decent simple entertainment if you're after a night in.
7/10