Before this episode aired, I was very nervous. The American Civil Rights movement is a very sensitive subject matter and there are so many ways that this episode could have gone wrong. Fortunately the writers, Malorie Blackman and Chris Chibnall, were able to navigate the difficulties and the result was a very good episode.
The most important thing that this episode gets right is that the Doctor and companions did not in any way inspire Rosa's act of protest that led to the bus boycott. Instead our time travellers are on the edge of events, trying to keep history free of interference from a another time traveller, a racist criminal called Krasko, who wants to create small changes that will stop the bus boycott and stop the Civil Rights movement from happening. There is no big plan for an alien invasion. The villain is all too-human, motivated by petty racism.
It's probably the closest to a pure historical since the William Hartnell years. We get references to Emmett Till and Ryan gets to meet Martin Luther King. As the villain is humanoid, we get no bug-eyed monsters. The enemies in this case are human. Unlike other episodes, where racism is allegorical with aliens, here it is very raw and real feeling.
I complained last time about the pacing problems. Although The Ghost Monument was set on a hostile alien planet, our regular characters never felt like they were in danger. This week, in part because of the grim subject matter, there was a lot more tension. Only minutes after leaving the Tardis, Ryan is slapped by a racist man. Every few moments there was peril afflicting our characters. It was Krasko, then it was the Police Officer. The characters were constantly kept on their toes. Their attempts to make Rosa get the bus were being disrupted and they had to improvise to make it work.
I continue to like this new Doctor. Jodie was effective, whether she was joking about being Banksy, or being serious when she confronts Krasko. The companions were also very good. Ryan and Yasmin both get to deal with racism. Ryan having to keep his cool was good. There was also a hint of chemistry between them. Graham was great. Him having to be the catalyst for Rosa Parks was good. He is fully supportive of Ryan. All were really effective at the end when they were reluctantly part of that bus journey.
The supporting cast were also very effective. Vinnette Robinson was good as Rosa Parks. She felt like a dignified human being, intelligent and brave. The show did not glamourise her or patronise her. It was very well done.
Krasko was an interesting villain. An escapee from stormcage with a vortex manipulator. He couldn't actually hurt anyone so could only manipulate. Some might wonder if he should be there or not. The story might have worked if he had been an ordinary time agent accidentally changing things. Still, his motivation of racism did fit in with the theme.
Mark Tonderai's direction was good. I particularly liked the opening scene of the camera following the bus and then moving off into an alleyway where the Tardis materialised. A nice continuous shot. The crane shot of the motel down to the Doctor and her friends was good as it showed them oppressed by its sign.
The only thing I wasn't sure about was the song 'Rise-Up'. It was effective in the scene where Rosa was arrested and where the Doctor talks about Rosa's importance in history. I don't think it needed to be in the ending credits.
Rosa was a good episode. Where the previous two episodes of Series 11 were safe introductions, this one feels as though it is trying new things and exploring new areas for the show. A proper success.
Rate = 9/10
No comments:
Post a Comment